Hello tlerickson73 - Since you are having this problem with both printers, there are three different universal print drivers for the LaserJet CP2025 located at this page (Windows 7 64-bit US version driver page) that may help you with this. Also check for any new updates from Microsoft to see if any have been released since this started happening. Nothing in the HP drivers have changed and since this worked in Office 2010 and not in 2013, I am having a bit of a time getting an update from HP for this.
Any new changes thus far regarding everyone's current issue? Try running those Microsoft updates and let me know if that helps or not.