Printer throwing up errors and printing blank pages

My HP DeskJet 4158e has recently had printing issues. The first year we had it everything worked fine. Recently it stopped printing in black ink. I could not figure out the issue so I did a factory reset. After which it printed the setup documents just fine. No issue. So I ran a few test prints to make sure the print heads were clean. No issue.

But when going to print a document or anything else I get blank pages when using black ink and sometimes while sending the print to the printer it errors out, with all the lights blinking on the printer. I'm about at my wits end with this thing. 

Also the blank pages happen no matter what PC or device I am printing from

I've checked to make sure the ink cartages are properly seated. Tried running the Diagnostic in HP smart. Nothing but lights blinking and errors.