Printer prints blue on photo paper despite having proper ink levels and printing fine on normal pape

I’m trying to print on my HP Envy 5640 printer. When I print the quality reports it prints fine, and I have done the clean print heads and align multiple times. But, when I print using 4x6 photo paper in the photo tray, it comes out with a heavy blue tint to it. My black and color ink cartridges are about 75% full. No filter is applied, and if I print the photo on plain paper it works perfectly fine. I’m using the HP Smart App and I’ve also tried printing directly from my camera roll